Carbon Market Chronicles: The Invisible Money
ECO is up to its ears in statements about carbon markets saving us all from climate armageddon. Even the COP presidency managed to graciously find some time in its busy schedule to organize a roundtable on scaling up voluntary carbon markets.
Delegates, we must not be reading the right media articles. Because so far, 2023 has not been sunshine and roses, but instead it’s been quite apocalyptic for carbon markets, with countless scandals emerging. Overestimated emissions reductions, forced displacement, sexual abuse; the list goes on. It has been so bad that, when announcing the US’s new Energy Transition Accelerator (read: carbon offset market), the only positive example of an emission trading market Secretary John Kerry could cite in his speech was a system that (a) didn’t involve carbon offsets, (b) didn’t focus on GHGs, and (c) was implemented 30 years ago!
One big question that still bothers ECO: where is the money? The (self-interested) predictions of banks and consultants describe a market worth tens or hundreds of billions of USD in a few years. Who will actually benefit from this money? Could it be those making the predictions? ECO suspects that is a possibility.
In the voluntary market, intermediaries buy and sell credits with zero transparency.
... Read more ...